The drop begins even
before she is born.
A woman has the most
eggs stored in her ovaries when she's
growing inside her mother.
As a 20-week-old fetus,
she's got 4 million to 6 million. As a
newborn, she's down to 1 million. As an
adolescent, she's holding on to 400,000.
At menopause, she's left with 1,000.
But the eggs start to
fray around her 35th birthday — long
before menopause. Their chromosomes no
longer divide properly. Response to
pregnancy hormones is sluggish.
Despite all the stories
about wonders worked on eggs, sperm and
embryos in science labs, no one has
discovered a drug or procedure that can
prod a human egg into being young again.
But scientists have
found other ways to overcome the body's
limitations and help infertile couples
bring a baby into the world. Fertility
technology has advanced considerably
since Louise Brown, the first "test tube
baby," was born in England in 1978.
From 1996, when the
Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention started officially keeping
track of fertility-clinic birth rates,
through 2004, the number of live births
in the U.S. as a result of assisted
reproductive technology (ART) more than
doubled, from 14,507 to 36,760.
In 2004, 37 percent of
ART cycles started by women younger than
35 who used their own eggs resulted in
live births. The numbers are lower for
older women who use their own eggs,
dropping to 4 percent for those older
than 42.
Using donated eggs or
embryos, however, boosts the percentages
for moms-to-be who are 35 and older.
According to the
American Society for Reproductive
Medicine, the majority of infertility
cases are treated with medication, such
as fertility drugs or surgery on the
reproductive organs.
Assisted reproductive
technology accounts for less than 3
percent of infertility services. But ART
grabs the most hearts, especially when a
celebrity like Brooke Shields is
splashed across the cover of People
magazine, marveling at her "miracle"
baby.
The ART of in
vitro
The most common form of
ART is in vitro fertilization, or IVF.
Here's the condensed version of how it's
done, minus the many delicate and
meticulous in-between steps and
monitoring: A woman's eggs are removed
from her ovaries, then fertilized with
her partner's sperm in vitro (Latin for
"in glass") in a laboratory. Three to
five days later, the fertilized eggs are
placed directly into the uterus. If all
goes well, nine months later.
Other ART techniques,
which we won't delve into in great
detail here because in vitro
fertilization comprises more than 99
percent of treatments, are gamete
intrafallopian transfer (GIFT) and
zygote intrafallopian transfer (ZIFT).
ART, alas, is an acronym-heavy field.
Variations include
implanting embryos that have been frozen
and thawed from a previous ART cycle or,
as Star reporter Anna Chang-Yen relates
in the accompanying first-person
article, using a donor's eggs.
Chang-Yen, 28, has
premature ovarian failure, meaning she
has run out of viable eggs before age
40. She and her husband, David, have
asked Chang-Yen's older sister, Shanna
Brittian, to donate eggs that will be
fertilized with David's sperm and
implanted into Anna's uterus.
Dr. Ashim Kumar and his
team at the Fertility and Surgical
Associates of California clinic in
Thousand Oaks are leading Anna, David
and Shanna through IVF.
During a recent
interview at his office, Kumar discussed
the most recent advancements in IVF.
ICSI: one egg,
one sperm
A breakthrough that's
actually been around for more than 10
years, but "a lot of people don't know
is available," Kumar said, is
intracytoplasmic sperm injection, or
ICSI (pronounced IK-see).
During in vitro
fertilization, eggs can be fertilized
"naturally" by placing 50,000 to 100,000
sperm around each egg; or with ICSI, by
injecting a single sperm into a mature
egg. ICSI is used when a woman's partner
has severe infertility problems or has
undergone a vasectomy but wants to use
his own sperm, not a donor's. Fertility
doctors can surgically extract the man's
sperm, even if he has had a vasectomy.
PGD: genetic
screening
Preimplantation genetic
diagnosis, or PGD, tests embryos for
genetic disorders before the embryos are
transferred to the uterus.
PGD, not yet offered
widely (it was used in 4 percent of ART
cycles in 2005), is for potential
parents with inherited genetic disorders
such as cystic fibrosis or muscular
dystrophy. In the lab, doctors can
determine which embryos are carriers and
transfer only those without the defect.
|
Photo by Joseph Garcia
"Unfortunately, when people
run out of choices, they can
go to the fringes of
medicine. That's where a
third or second opinion
comes in." Dr. Ashim
Kumar, of Fertility
and Surgical Associates of
California clinic in
Thousand Oaks. |
Other candidates for PGD,
Kumar said, are women who have had
repeated miscarriages. Recurring
pregnancy loss, he said, might occur
"because part of one chromosome in the
egg or sperm breaks off and attaches to
another, so there's missing material on
one chromosome and additional (material)
on another."
During in vitro
fertilization, he said, "we can make a
window in the shell of the embryo,
extract one cell, fix it onto a slide
and stain the slide to see what part of
the chromosomes are present."
More controversial is
using PGD for a nonmedical reason:
choosing the sex of a baby.
Injuring without
harm
Kumar also described a
technique for women who can't get
pregnant because embryos won't take hold
in their uterus. Fibroids or polyps,
which are often the cause, can be
removed surgically.
But for cases when
fibroids or polyps aren't the culprit,
Israeli researchers have had success
with "injuring the endometrium," a
procedure that "sounds more invasive
than it is," Kumar said.
|
Resources
- A one-stop resource for
support and education about
infertility is RESOLVE: The
National Infertility
Association, a nonprofit
organization that promotes equal
access to "all family-building
options for men and women
experiencing infertility or
other reproductive disorders."
The organization has a network
of nationwide chapters,
including one in Ventura County,
that offer support groups and
education programs. To link to
the Ventura County page on
RESOLVE's Web site, visit
southwest.resolve.org and
click on "Find a RESOLVE near
you" under "Quick Links"; or
call the RESOLVE of Southern
California HelpLine at
877-203-7776.
- For
success rates and other
information about individual
clinics in the United States,
access the Centers for Disease
Control's "ART Success Rates:
National Summary and Fertility
Clinic Report" at
www.cdc.gov/ART. |
The technique involves
taking a biopsy of the uterus using an
instrument called a pipelle before an
IVF cycle. "It supposedly increases
implantation rates by 50 percent," Kumar
said. Researchers aren't sure why the
pipelle treatment works. The technique
is experimental, because only one group
of researchers has studied it. Still, he
said, his clinic offers the procedure
because "the risk is minimal — maybe
five seconds of discomfort — and the
benefit is pretty significant. It holds
promise for someone who's gone through
failed IVF cycles."
Multiples, not
by choice
Sometimes, baby makes
two or three or more. One of the
downsides (or upsides, depending on how
you look at it) of ART, which offers the
opportunity to implant more than one
embryo, is the associated rise in
multiple births (twins, triplets and
beyond). Multiple gestation is more
dangerous for the mom and babies,
potentially leading to premature birth,
low birth weight and other problems.
The ASRM has issued
guidelines about the number of embryos
that should be implanted, Kumar said, so
patients should ask the clinic whether
it follows those recommendations.
Multiple gestation
raises an inherent conflict of interest,
however.
"How we're graded (by
the CDC) is our pregnancy rates, and
it's easy to increase rates by replacing
more embryos," Kumar explained. "But if
you have a good IVF lab and do things
carefully, you're going to get good
pregnancy rates even by putting in fewer
embryos," Kumar said, noting that his
clinic follows a two-embryo guideline.
Many European countries,
he said, will transfer only one embryo.
But those countries pay for every cycle
of IVF, unlike the U.S., where most
insurance plans don't cover even one
cycle. If a couple are spending their
life savings on IVF, Kumar said, "it's
unfair to say they have to accept a
lower pregnancy rate by only putting one
embryo back."
Freeze embryos,
not eggs
Kumar also described a
new ART procedure that hasn't had a high
success rate: oocyte cryopreservation,
or freezing unfertilized eggs for later
use.
|
Photo by Joseph Garcia
The
micro manipulator attached
to an inverted compound
microscope is used in the
IVF lab at Fertility and
Surgical Associates of
California for in vitro
fertilization procedures. |
Oocyte cryopreservation
is not the same as embryo
cryopreservation, a more reliable
freezing procedure.
Embryos created through
IVF can be preserved in liquid nitrogen,
"and when we thaw them they have a very
good chance of survival," Kumar said.
Eggs, Kumar said, "have relatively high
water content and are difficult to thaw
and freeze effectively."
Freezing embryos lets
women implant another embryo if a
previous IVF cycle fails. The goal of
freezing eggs is to preserve her
fertility. For example, an unmarried
woman in her 30s who wants to have a
baby someday can freeze her eggs until
she finds the right partner. "She'll
then have the eggs of somebody who's
younger and can conceive a baby with her
own eggs," Kumar said. Or a woman going
through chemotherapy can freeze her eggs
before starting the treatment.
Yes, Kumar said, babies
have been born from eggs that were
frozen, but the chance of that happening
is extremely low.
"Unfortunately, when
people run out of choices, they can go
to the fringes of medicine," Kumar said.
"That's where a second or third opinion
comes in. If somebody tells you they're
one of five centers in the world or
country offering this, you should think,
Why is everyone else not offering
this?'"
Despite all the fancy
genetic work, Kumar said much of the
increase in success rates for
infertility treatment is "about
improvements in the IVF laboratory.
There's constant attention to what's
happening in the lab — the culture
medium, the air quality. Every little
thing helps. If you leave an embryo on a
countertop unheated for 15 seconds, it's
not going to do well."
And he reminds patients
who balk at what they perceive as low
pregnancy rates for IVF (below 40
percent): "If you look at conception
that occurs naturally in a young healthy
couple, you don't have implantation
rates of 60, 70 or 80 percent. It's just
not true even in nature, a perfect
system. I think we're trying to beat
nature at its game, and it's fraught
with complications. We shouldn't
overestimate our abilities."